May 8, 2023

8 Myths: Heat Pumps vs. Furnaces – Debunked for Homeowners in Waterloo and Guelph Area

Discover the truth about heat pumps and furnaces as we debunk eight common myths for homeowners in the Waterloo and Guelph area. Stay informed and save on your energy bills.

heat pump system

As a homeowner in the Waterloo and Guelph area, you’re likely looking for the most efficient and cost-effective ways to keep your home comfortable year-round. 

Let’s face it, the climate here is all over the place, with the summers being some of the hottest in the country and the winters being about as dark and as cold as it gets. We get the extremes of both ends of the scale, so making sure you’re well looked after throughout is a top priority.

That said, there are so many options available for heating and cooling that it’s easy to get caught up in the myths surrounding heat pumps and gas furnaces. 

To help you make an informed decision, we’ve debunked eight common myths about these central heating systems, allowing you to understand the facts and make the best decision for your home.

Myth 1: Heat Pumps are Only for Heating

Heat pumps have recently gained popularity as an energy-efficient alternative to traditional gas furnaces. However, many people believe they only provide heating. 

The reality is that heat pumps can both heat and cool your home. By reversing the refrigeration cycle, heat pumps can also provide cooling during warmer months, making them a versatile HVAC option for homeowners.

Myth 2: Gas Furnaces are More Efficient than Heat Pumps

While gas furnaces have been the go-to option for heating with gas, heat pumps do give them a run for their money. 

Thanks to technological advancements, modern heat pumps can be just as efficient, if not more so, than gas furnaces, especially when compared to older units. This is especially true in milder climates, where heat pumps can maintain their efficiency even during the coldest months.

Myth 3: Heat Pumps Don’t Work Well in Cold Climates

canada in the winter

It’s a common misconception that heat pumps aren’t suitable for cold climates like those in the Waterloo and Guelph area. 

While it’s true that older heat pump models may struggle in extreme cold, new cold climate heat pump models are designed to handle lower temperatures efficiently. Some can even operate at temperatures as low as -25°C, making them a viable option for heating in colder regions.

Myth 4: Gas Furnaces Provide Better Air Quality

There’s a common misconception that gas furnaces provide better indoor air quality than heat pumps. 

However, both systems can potentially maintain good air quality when paired with proper filtration and ventilation. In fact, since heat pumps don’t produce combustion gases, they can be a cleaner option for those concerned about indoor air quality.

Myth 5: Heat Pumps are Noisy and Disruptive

While early heat pump models were known to be noisy, technological advancements have significantly reduced the noise levels in modern units. Today’s heat pumps operate quietly and efficiently, making them a non-disruptive option for homeowners, so you don’t have to worry about being disturbed.

Myth 6: Gas Furnaces Last Longer than Heat Pumps

The lifespan of both heat pumps and gas furnaces depends on factors such as usage, maintenance, and installation quality. 

With proper care, both systems can last 15-20 years or more. However, heat pumps may require fewer repairs over time, as they have fewer mechanical components than gas furnaces.

Myth 7: Heat Pumps are More Expensive to Install


While it’s true that heat pumps can be more expensive to install initially, they can also provide long-term savings on energy bills and can turn out more affordable in the long run because they’re more energy efficient.

Myth 8: Gas Furnaces are Always the Better Option

While gas furnaces have been a popular choice for central heating in the past, heat pumps have become an increasingly attractive alternative for many homeowners. The best choice for your home depends on factors such as your climate, energy costs, and personal preferences. 

In milder climates, heat pumps can offer greater energy efficiency and versatility for both heating and cooling. In colder climates, modern heat pumps can still be an effective option, but gas furnaces may provide more consistent heating during extreme cold snaps.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, understanding the facts about heat pumps and gas furnaces is essential for homeowners in the Waterloo and Guelph area who are looking to make informed decisions about their HVAC systems. 

By debunking these common myths, you can choose the right central heating solution for your home, ensuring comfort and efficiency year-round. 

To determine the best option for your needs, consult our expert team here at Hy-Mark.

Let us help you choose the best heat pump or gas furnace to keep your home comfortable and energy-efficient all year long. 

Get in touch with us now and experience the difference that Hy-Mark can make for your home!

Call Our Office At (226) 917-2686 For A Free Home Comfort Consultation.

company icon